The Phoenix New Times, which was the only newspaper to cover the initial investigation into the death of Jana Van Voorhis, reports that four members of the Final Exit Network have been arrested. Van Voorhis had minor physical complaints, but had a long history of struggles with psychological and emotional issues.
From the article:
Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas announced a few minutes ago that investigators from his office have busted four people on murder charges in the 2005 “assisted suicide” death of a seriously mentally ill Phoenix woman.
New Times broke the news of this unusual and tragic case in 2007 in an extensive piece we called “Death Wish.”
The four defendants — who include retired Scottsdale resident Frank Langsner, a retired college professor — have been charged with conspiracy to commit murder.
Langsner and Wye Hale-Rowe, another so-called “exit guide” from the Final Exit Network (a national assisted suicide outfit based in Georgia), also are facing manslaughter charges.
Phoenix police records (and reporting by New TImes) showed Langsner and Hale-Rowe, both in their 80s, were present when 58-year-old Jana Van Voorhis (seen in the photo in her younger days) killed herself by inhaling helium through a hose, with an oxygen-eliminating hood snugly over her head.
Langsner and Hale-Rowe (a retired family therapist and great-grandmother from Aurora, Colorado) then staged the scene at Van Voorhis’ Phoenix condo to make it look as if the woman had just gone to sleep in her bed and died of unknown causes.
In its literature, Final Exit calls itself “the only organization in the United States willing to help individuals who are not `terminally ill’–six months or less to live–hasten their deaths. No other organization in the U.S. has the courage to make this commitment.”
All of the evidence suggests that Jana Van Voorhis, however, was not suffering from a terminal illness when she died, but had suffered from chronic mental illness.
The New Times promises “more on this one soon.”
I look forward to it. So far, the coverage coming out of Arizona has been much more professional than the coverage coming out of Atlanta and Chicago. –Stephen Drake
Does this case involve the hold-their-hand kind of “assistance” (restraint)? Is that the basis of the charges, or is it for supplying the means to commit suicide?
or both?
I live in Arizona, and I, too, have been impressed with the local news coverage of this story. For once, the press and police are calling Final Exit’s actions what they are: murder. (I’m so tired of Final Exit speak! I like words to *mean* what they actually say; I like to know what words *mean.*) The prosecutors in Maricopa County are like terriers: fiesty, tough, and focused. They’ll get the job done right. They make one proud to be an Arizonan!
The visual image of someone putting “a snuggly fitting hood over..”(my)”head” is unbelievable. Egads.
Like I said before, I am not a helium (mylar) balloon.
Bob,
The details on the level of “assistance” given by FEN members are in contention. Members themselves have given several different versions – from saying they don’t touch at all to saying they hold their hands. That they can’t get their stories straight makes me think the worst. To be honest, though, I’m inclined to think the worst of them, anyway. –Stephen
Anonymous,
I wouldn’t be overenthusiastic about the Arizona coverage. The Phoenix New Times is to be commended for its coverage, including the initial breaking of the news into Van Voorhis’ death. Similarly, Amanda Lee Myers of the AP in Arizona did a great job reporting on the FEN’s training manual.
Having said that, I want to make it clear that – as far as I can tell – not a single paper in Arizona covered the story about Van Voorhis and FEN until very recently. The New Times did that work on its own.
The Arizona Daily Star has been especially bad, allowing an op-ed by FEN board member Earl Wettstein that contained the false claim that FEN helped those who were “terminal.” But then again, the Daily Star hadn’t devoted a single sentence to Van Voorhis, so I guess they didn’t know. –Stephen Drake